Sunday, December 4, 2011

My perception of Taiwan before embarking on the research



Before I embarked on the research about Taiwan, I have a shallow level of knowledge about its culture, traditions and society for I have not travelled there before. From the youtube videos, advertisements and word of mouth exposure, I perceived Taiwan as a modernized country. A country with high standard of living and well developed transportation network and well known for its pop singers such as Jay Chou, S.H.E, Jolin Tsai, Zhang Huimei etc and pop music. I concluded that Taiwan is also a food and shopping paradise, famous for its snacks and night markets due to word of mouth.

I feel that the primary motivators to travel to Taiwan are the desire to see their new cultures, lifestyles, music and food and for relaxation and enjoyment, to have a getaway from the busy hustle and bustle of city life. My curiosity towards the indigenous groups in Taiwan aroused. I presumed that being the minority, the indigenous groups in Taiwan could be threatened due to modernization.

Representation of the culture of Taiwan





Taiwan night market’s snacks known as xiao chi are definitely the first thing that comes across a tourist’s mind when we talk about the country. Besides being a great place to shop for bargains and feel the pulse of Taiwan's after-hours life, the authentic Taiwanese food can also be sampled at the night market. A stroll inside any night market is a guarantee to get tourists’ mouth watering as the smell of the food tempts their taste buds. (Taiwan Tourism Bureau, 2009- 2011)

The top ten Taiwan night market snacks include mini soup dumplings, crispy salt and pepper chicken, stinky tofu, oyster vermicelli, ba-wan (Taiwanese meatball), chicken rice, braised pork rice, shrimp rolls, oyster omelet and pearl milk tea. (Government Information Office, Republic of China (Taiwan), 2010)

Culture and traditions of Amis (阿美族)

Taiwanese government has officially recognized 14 aboriginal tribes in Taiwan and Amis is the largest indigenous group today. They are settled along the east coast, primarily in the Taitung and Hualien areas. (Liu, 2009) The Amis traditionally did not carry out much cultivation. (Robbins, 2008) Since they live near the coast, fishing is their main source of wealth, but hunting is still practiced. (Liu, 2009)

Millet is a staple grain that is cultivated by the Amis. Summer is when millet ripens and is harvested. Each village decides on the appropriate dates for holding a harvest festival, another example of the culture and tradition of this large tribe. The first of the celebrations begins in mid-July with the last ending in late August.



The festival continues for several days with members of each village dancing continuously in a circle to the chants of a selected "singer". Tourists may be encouraged to join the dance circle. Thus, this is an excellent time to visit Amis villages. (Robbins, 2008) Therefore, the Amis are well-known for their rich music and dance tradition. (Government Information Office, Republic of China(Taiwan) , 2011)



In addition, they are also appreciated for their beautiful red coloured clothing and accessories. The Amis excel at woodcarving and at creating beaded jewellery and decorative items. For more information about Taiwan’s indigenous arts and handicrafts, go to www.tribe-asia.com. Uniquely, the Amis are the only aboriginal tribe on the island of Taiwan to practice the art of pottery making. (Vost, 1995)

Authenticity of the culture from the point of view of a tourist


Two years ago, my friend, Penelope Toh, went on a group tour to Taiwan, Hualien with her family and cultural show was included in the package. She had a first-hand cultural dance experience with the Amis. To a certain extent, Penelope felt that Amish culture is authentic and genuine as the Ami are dressed in their traditional costumes, ready to convey their culture through interactive and engaging performances, plays and dance.


On the flipside, Penelope shared that Amish culture and traditions are certainly more than just the cultural dance and bridal ceremony. However, the Ami only showcased the most entertaining elements of their culture. Furthermore, they moderated and shortened the show so that it appears appealing to the tourists. This results in simplification of the Amish culture.

Accordingly to Penelope, Amish culture has also been commodified as she highlighted that tourist experiences are transformed into tangible commodities. For example, taking pictures and putting it into a frame to sell it to tourists at a price as souvenirs.



Tourism impacts on the authentic culture of Taiwan and the Amis

The positive socio-cultural impacts are strengthening communities and encouraging civic involvement and traditions.

For example, Taiwan’s biggest movie, “Seediq Bale’ sparks the indigenous tourism, along the east coast of Taiwan where more than 40 Amis aboriginal tribes reside today. (Foreman, 2011) As stated in the news, "Seediq Bale" has created a surge in indigenous pride. The indigenous groups are now using their indigenous names in preference to their Chinese names for they are proud of their indigenous roots.

The director of the film, Wei Te-Sheng shared “ A friend from the Paiwan tribe is packaging a "no electricity tour"; visitors can have a deeper cultural experience, connecting with the landscape, hunting at night, learning survival skills and living in the same conditions experienced by the indigenous people.” (Foreman, 2011) Indeed, the information is accurate when the bureau’s administration office of the East Coast National Scenic Area said that the movie has revived interest in the island’s aboriginal culture (Taiwan News, 2011) and aboriginal people to contribute to society more directly. (Foreman, 2011)

The negative socio-cultural impact is conflicts with traditional land-uses. As mentioned in Taipei Times, Amis representative Konon Panay said the central government did not define and grant Aboriginal lands, instead it has been depriving Aborigines of their lands in the name of development. (Chang, 2011)

The Eastern Development Act was approved in June by the legislature and aims to develop land in Hualien and Taitung counties, allowing big developers to destroy land traditionally owned by Aborigines and threatening to ruin the lives of Amis Aborigines, Panay said. (Chang, 2011)

The government of Taiwan has taken steps to sustain the culture of indigenous groups. For instance, the island government spends 1.5 billion Taiwan dollars (51 million US dollars) per year on preservation of the indigenous culture. Taiwan government agencies aim to establish an autonomous village, to open as early December, where Thao language and ceremonies can flourish without outside influence. They have officials plan to step up language preservation work and develop a law to strengthen tribal rights over ancestral land. They also sponsored art and architecture classes for children. (Jennings, 2011)

The focus of their calendar of events

Taiwan’s calendar of events focuses mainly on their culture and traditions. This is evident for the three most important festivals celebrated in Taiwan are based on culture and traditions. Lunar New Year (also known as Spring Festival in Taiwan and it is celebrated according to lunar calendar) and Mid-Autumn Festival (falls on 15th of eighth lunar month). (Liu, 2009) Dragon Boat Festival (falls on fifth day of the fifth month in the lunar calendar). (Liu, 2009). Interestingly, it is the only sporting event in the world to have been inspired by a drowning bureaucrat. (Chris & Bates, 2001)

Other festivals associated with their culture and traditions include Tomb Sweeping Festival (which falls on March 5), Beigang Matsu Festival (held once a year on the goddess Matsu’s birthday at around April or May of the lunar calendar), Ghost Month (from the first day of the seventh lunar month till the 15th day of the month), Confucious’ Birthday (which falls on September 28). (Chris & Bates, 2001)

Dachia Matsu Cultural Festival


Disneyization of Taiwan

Theming

Jurassic restaurant: dinosaur themed restaurant

The three-story Jurassic restaurant in Taipei opened in 1988. The menu is traditional; it includes stinky tofu and frogs cooked in soy sauce, but it is the decorations visitors come for. (Switek, 2009) Dinosaur skeletons are on the roof and on the sides of the building, while 6-metre-long dinosaur skeletons and T-rex skulls decorate the interior. (NTDTV, 2009) Jurassic restaurant was launched during a time when there was a glut of wild-west-themed establishments in Taipei. (Switek, 2009)

The restaurant owner, Mr Huang Pei-Song said that their idea was to have a theme that cannot be easily replicated. Why dinosaurs? He explained that simply because they do not exist now. Regardless of the generation people were born in, they do not exist and so they would always remain a sense of freshness. (NTDTV, 2009) Therefore, as mentioned in the video below, even after 20 years, new customers are still surprised when they dine there. While most wild-west themes slipped into extinction, Jurassic restaurant holds on (Switek, 2009) and it has succeeded as they are able to provide a unique experience that customers are seeking for.



Besides dinosaur themed restaurant, there are also numerous of popular themed restaurant in Taiwan. Some examples are jail themed restaurant, toilet themed restaurant, A380 themed restaurant and hospital themed restaurant. The themes are the unique selling point that attracts customers to the restaurants.

Hybrid consumption

Taipei zoo is an example of how the concept of hybrid consumption can be applied. The zoo itself becomes a destination and the principle is not purely to visit the animals but getting people to stay longer through things that they offer. Besides the animals as the main attraction in zoo, there are children’s zoo, food and beverage outlets and souvenir shops to keep your children entertained, fulfill your psychological needs and allow you to do some shopping.




Another example would be Leofoo village theme
park. Since it is not possible to complete the tour of Leofoo Village Theme Park on a single day due to its size, it is planning to include an international hotel (AsiaRooms, 2011), to meet the physiological needs of the visitors. They also have the plan of including a huge garden. The theme park is more than just thrilling rides, having a garden allows relaxation and it is appealing to market segment such as the elderly. Restaurants, shops and performances attract them to spend longer time there.




Merchandising

The souvenir shops in Taipei zoo sell merchandise to the tourists and the purpose is to maximize the opportunity for the customers to buy so as to generate sales. The sales made from the merchandise is one of the components that contribute to the profit of the zoo. So what did Taipei zoo do? Their merchandise has a suitably attired character on them; the pandas. They provide their own merchandise such as t-shirts, cups, hats and masks that represents pandas with Taipei zoo logo. (Mac, 2011) The t-shirts that tourist could buy acts as literally the walking advertisement of the zoo.

Performative Labour

At Fatimid, Taiwan maid café, the staff becomes the actor on stage. Besides dressing up as maid to get into the character, the “maid” needs to address the customer as “master” and place them as their priority. They are required to be smiley and friendly at all times to provide
good quality of service.


Reflection of Taiwan’s society, culture and tourism

After the research, I realized that Taiwan’s tourism has becomes a social event due to the shared social world, creating an increased likelihood of quality experiences in tourism. Culture impacts tourism. Nowadays the influence of pop music, desire to see new culture, lifestyles and food in Taiwan have created demand for tourism.

On the other hand, tourism also impacts culture. For instance, due to tourist’s demand, commodification, dilution and loss of culture occur. This is especially so in indigenous groups. Tourism impacts society. When there is a tourism demand for culture from indigenous groups, it brings about economic benefits. Unfortunately, the distribution of benefits is unequal and unfair most of the time as they are the minorities. In conclusion, what we need to understand is that “no man is an island”; tourism, culture and society are closely linked and they affect each other.

References

AsiaRooms. (2011). Leofoo Village Theme Park Taiwan. Retrieved December 5, 2011, from AsiaRooms Web site: http://www.asiarooms.com/en/travel-guide/taiwan/taiwan-tourist-attractions/leofoo-village-theme-park-taiwan.html
Chang, R. (2011, December 6). Aborigines slam draft autonomy act, mull lawsuits. Taipei Times , p. 3.
Chris, & Bates, L.-l. (2001). Culture Shock Taiwan. Singapore: Times Media Private Limited Times Centre.
Earl, W. (1992, January 6). Preservation Or Perversion? Retrieved December 5, 2011, from Taiwan Review Web site: http://taiwanreview.nat.gov.tw/site/Tr/ct.asp?xItem=97959&CtNode=1361
Foreman, B. (2011, November 23). 'Seediq Bale': Taiwan's biggest movie sparks indigenous tourism. CNNGo .
Government Information Office, Republic of China (Taiwan) . (2011, March 18). Taiwan aboriginal Amis music and dance on show at music festivals in Bangkok, Patthalung, and Wangnamkeaw. Retrieved December 4, 2011, from Portal of Republic of China (Taiwan) Diplomatic Missions: http://www.roc-taiwan.org/ct.asp?xItem=188751&ctNode=2237&mp=3&nowPage=3&pagesize=45
Government Information Office, Republic of China (Taiwan). (2010). Taiwan Night Market Food Top 10. Retrieved December 3, 2011, from Taiwan's Night Markets Web site: http://www.taiwan.gov.tw/lp.asp?ctNode=1989&CtUnit=583&BaseDSD=7&mp=1002
Jennings, R. (2011, December 5). Taiwan aborigines back in spotlight as cultures fade. Asia-Pacific News .
Liu, A. C. (2009). Taiwan A to Z: the essential cultural guide. Taipei: The Community Services Center.
Mac. (2011, October 27). Where Panda Meets Tiger - Taipei Zoo . Retrieved December 5, 2011, from Taiwan - cost of living blog: http://taiwancost.blogspot.com/2011/10/where-panda-meets-tiger-taipei-zoo.html
NTDTV. (2009, June 9). Dinosaur Themed Restaurant a Hit in Taiwan. Retrieved December 5, 2011, from New Tang Dynasty Television Web site: http://english.ntdtv.com/ntdtv_en/ns_asia/2009-06-09/874819878087.html
Robbins, C. (2008, August 5). Amis tribe: Village-based culture. Retrieved December 4, 2011, from Culture.tw Web site: http://www.culture.tw/index.php?option=com_content&task=rdmap&Itemid=262&id=835
Switek, B. (2009, June 11). Dining With Dinosaurs in Taiwan. Retrieved December 5, 2011, from Smithsonian Web site: http://blogs.smithsonianmag.com/dinosaur/2009/06/dining-with-dinosaurs-in-taiwan/
Taiwan News. (2011, October 17). ‘Seediq Bale’ sparks interest in indigenous tourism. Taiwan News .
Taiwan Tourism Bureau. (2009- 2011). Night Markets in Taiwan. Retrieved December 3, 2011, from Taiwan The Heart of Asia Web site: http://www.go2taiwan.net/monthly_selection.php?sqno=19
Vost, C. (1995). The tribes of Taiwan. Retrieved December 4, 2011, from Travel in Taiwan Culture: http://www.sinica.edu.tw/tit/culture/0795_TribesOfTaiwan.html